Health & Medical Cancer & Oncology

Physicians 'Hit the Barricades' Over Cancer Costs

Physicians 'Hit the Barricades' Over Cancer Costs

Taking to the Barricades


Dr. Marshall: We live in a world of the third-party payer. It's not as if the individual patient is writing a check for these drugs. It's some other person. You, David, come from a world with the ultimate third-party payer, where decision-making is made on a national scale.

Dr. Kerr: Yes.

Dr. Marshall: We used to decry the methodology used by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) committee. Now, all of a sudden, it has become the hot way to do things. Could you talk a little bit about the culture in your world [United Kingdom] and drug decision-making around these high-cost medicines?

Dr. Kerr: There are a couple of points to pick up on. The first is what you mentioned about doctors as activists. Usually the way that we go about things is silently, in the halls of power, using influence to lobby. But there is a growing sense that doctors are "taking to the barricades." They are doing it through Blood. They are doing it through articles in Oncology. They are doing it through op-ed pieces in the New York Times. Trotsky said, "It takes 3 people on a corner to start a revolution." This could be it.

There is a sense that doctors are standing out. They are doing it in a different way. This may come back to Trotsky's idea and make me sound left-wing. (I see you moving away from me.) But within socialized healthcare in the National Health Service (NHS), I was involved with Alan Milburn, who was our Health Secretary. As I become older, I'm becoming more of a public health doc, and I'm starting to understand why, if you make honest, open, transparent decisions about whether we, as a society, can afford these drugs, it is much better than just not talking about it.

It's much better than rationing (a terrible word) by the back door or rationing through silence or rationing by excluding large elements of the population. NICE was set up to be equitable. When I was a kid, the administrative units of the NHS were set up so that if you and I lived on opposite sides of the same street, my health unit might say, "Yes, you can get imatinib." But on your side of the street, no, you could not. It was post-code prescribing, a lottery of care. NICE was set up nationally to give us a framework that was open, understandable, and scalable; so if you feel you could afford $100,000 or $200,000 per quality-adjusted life-year, go for it. We think we can afford less than that. But perhaps if you are an Indian citizen, you can afford less still, and so on. I like it because it's open and honest. You can see the workings of the machine rather than just hearing, "I can't afford that one."

SHARE
RELATED POSTS on "Health & Medical"
Reasons Why There Is So Much Skin Cancer Now Days
Reasons Why There Is So Much Skin Cancer Now Days
Breast Cancer Screening (PDQ®): Screening - Health Professional Information [NCI]-Special Population
Breast Cancer Screening (PDQ®): Screening - Health Professional Information [NCI]-Special Population
Mesothelioma – An Overview To A Deadly Cancer
Mesothelioma – An Overview To A Deadly Cancer
Is Massage A Natural Pain Relief?
Is Massage A Natural Pain Relief?
Could the HPV Test Replace the Pap Test?
Could the HPV Test Replace the Pap Test?
Diagnostic Tests - PET Scans
Diagnostic Tests - PET Scans
Elderly Receiving Neoadjuvant Chemoradiation for Rectal Cancer
Elderly Receiving Neoadjuvant Chemoradiation for Rectal Cancer
Routine Mammograms Found Not Helpful for Most Women Over 70
Routine Mammograms Found Not Helpful for Most Women Over 70
Meaty Diet Linked to Pancreatic Cancer
Meaty Diet Linked to Pancreatic Cancer
Advances in Transplantation Strategies for Multiple Myeloma
Advances in Transplantation Strategies for Multiple Myeloma
Bioavailability of Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitors
Bioavailability of Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitors
Tracking and Journaling the Cancer Journey
Tracking and Journaling the Cancer Journey
What You Need to Know About Benign Multicystic Mesothelioma
What You Need to Know About Benign Multicystic Mesothelioma
Essential Good Nutrition for Cancer Patients.
Essential Good Nutrition for Cancer Patients.
Stage 4 Lung Cancer - What Is It?
Stage 4 Lung Cancer - What Is It?
Wigs Help Patients Handle the Challenges of Treatment
Wigs Help Patients Handle the Challenges of Treatment
University Of Chicago Scientists Provide New Evidence For Cellular Cause Of Sids
University Of Chicago Scientists Provide New Evidence For Cellular Cause Of Sids
Oncotype DX as a Decision Tool in Early Breast Cancer
Oncotype DX as a Decision Tool in Early Breast Cancer
Practice of Medicine: Anxiety Up, Morale Down
Practice of Medicine: Anxiety Up, Morale Down
Surviving Breast Cancer - A Husband' s View
Surviving Breast Cancer - A Husband' s View
Breast Cancer Prevention Tips
Breast Cancer Prevention Tips
Journal Article: Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Stage 2 Colon Cancer
Journal Article: Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Stage 2 Colon Cancer
The D'Amico Classification System for Prostate Cancer
The D'Amico Classification System for Prostate Cancer
The Common Signs and Symptoms of Pancreatic Cancer
The Common Signs and Symptoms of Pancreatic Cancer

Leave Your Reply

*